It’s taken me several hours to calm down before i felt composed enough to write this. It’s my fault, I should have seen this coming, but sometimes betrayal takes you by surprise and you miss the warning signs which were there.
This was the warning sign, Neil Mackay warming them up a few days before.
So, after two home made latté, a tuna wrap and a couple of hours killing zombies in Fallout76 to calm the anger. I’m ready to lay out my thoughts.
This is a public reply to Alyn Smith, Angus Robertson, Stewart MacDonald for what I consider to be a very foolish and misguided article in the Herald today. I’m not going to link to it and give the Herald the benefit of clicks and hence advertising revenue, so the tweet below details it, with screenshots.
“Interesting that senior SNP figures chose the weekend of the indy rally to cooperate with – surprise! – Neil Mackay on a massive witch-hunt/smear operation against Yes supporters in a Unionist newspaper” – @WIngsScotland
It’s very interesting that >90% of the article is attacking their own side, including using the extremely offensive, pejorative term ‘Cybernat’ and there is a tiny paragraph on the last page casually mentioning Unionist trolls, almost as an afterthought.
Let’s tackle these two first and establish why Twitter is so important.
“Cybernat is a term used in the media of the United Kingdom to refer pejoratively to online supporters of Scottish independence and the Scottish National Party.
The term was apparently coined by Lord Foulkes and was used by Scottish Labour leader Iain Gray in 2009. It gained greater prominence during 2013, after mainstream media sources reported that Sir Chris Hoy had been subject to online abuse for expressing his support for unionism in Scotland. ” – Wikipedia
It’s worth reading that Wikipedia article for one very important and fundemental fact about online social media abuse – Its overwhelmingly done by Unionists against Independanistas. Before the Referendum, Indy supporters were almost 3x more likely to experience abuse than Unionists and after it was merely double the rate.
“In March 2014 a Survation poll for the Scottish Sunday Express found that around 13% of Scots had been subject to abuse either online or face to face. The poll found that about 8% of those intending to vote No at the time had experienced such abuse with the figure for those intending to vote yes at 21%.
Post-referendum, a Panelbase poll for Wings over Scotland found that in terms of online abuse specifically, 11% of those who had voted No had experienced online abuse compared to 20% of those who had voted Yes.”
Way to go fellas! Giving credability and weight to a smear term, coined by your political and philosophical enemies who are already MORE guilty of online abuse and then use it against your own side and most loyal supporters rather than, you know, defending them! Are you insane?
No, seriously; Angus, Neil and Alyn … are you living in La La Land?
Twitter and the internet at large can be equally a delightful and a scary place, full of people with strong opinions, but Twitter and other forms of social media is incredibly important to the independence campaign.
Why? Simply put, it’s the only place where ordinary Scots get representation for their beliefs, feelings and thoughts about Scottish politics and get to talk about what they want as the future for themselves and their kin and to join together to campaign and plan.
We are not allowed to comment on BBC Scotland new articles. All of our papers, bar The National, are Unionist leaning (yes, so is The Herald) and Independence supporters get lied to and lied about by Journalists on those platforms. Lets look at a few recent examples.
Firstly, the BBC Scotland Business Editor, Douglas Fraser, choosing to belittle and mock a fair comment from an ordinary punter feeling misrepresented.
Then, Political Editor, Nick Eardly, outright lying about coverage during the SNP Spring conference, it wasn’t on every day and they even interrupted Nicola Sturgeon in favour of the Snooker. Read the comments as Nick is ripped a new arsehole.
Lastly, for the BBC, my open Q to Nick Eardley on why they blatently lied and misrepresented about the result of a key currency vote, which of course was ignored.
“Public Q for @BBCScotlandNews, @nickeardleybbc and @BBCScotland. Why did BBC blatently lie about the currency vote at SNP Conf when first published and why have you edited the story SIX times since? It’s all kept here – primary evidence” – Gavin Barrie
So, with no other platform to fight back against the immense power of the BBC and newspapers, of course people take to Social Media. Sometimes it gets heated, but if you don’t like what you see, then you block, mute or politelty engage, like adults.
Nobody from The SNP are visible on twitter refuting the lies from the BBC and the mainstream press. Their fact check team is a joke. It’s almost entirely @WingsScotland and people like myself.
Angus, Neil, Alyn, you don’t attack your own supporters and hand ammunition to your enemy, who will villify said people and smear them. Let’s remind ourselves how that goes, with this classic smear piece from the Daily Mail before #indyref1.
In case you’ve forgotten, this was one of the first times that the mainstream media tried to silence Wings Over Scotland.
So that’s my first point. They are attacking the wrong target and undermining their own supporters.
My second point, is that Alyn Smith, as much as I like him, is a massive, massive hypocrit. (I’ll come to Neil Mackay in a bit…)
There is growing and vocal movement of Women and their allies (including me) in Scotland, who don’t approve of, and are very concerned about measures that appear to be growing to change processes that allow trans people to re-assign gender and give them access to previously female only safe spaces.
[If you disagree with this short summation, I’d be more than happy to discuss it on Twitter and I apologise for the brevity, but the point here isn’t the arguements, but the genuine and shocking mysogeny, hate speech and abuse that’s going on towards women.]
Notably, this has been led recently by the very admirable Joan McAlpine, who has made a point of listening to and amplifying Womens’ and allies voices and concerns. This has made her the target of some horrific online abuse, most notably by a user going by the twitter handle @Montague90 .
You won’t find him active at the mo as he was reported to Twitter and Police Scotland for a lovely selection of tweets – examples below.
TERF is now recognised as hate speech by Twitter, never mind all the fucking off and the mysogeny … But you know the real kicker is who Jordon is exactly?
Jordon is Alyn Smith’s Long term partner. Yes really.
“OK that’s it, I don’t think I’ll be voting in the European elections. Alyn Smith’s boyfriend Jordon was one of the most abusive tweeters I’ve seen in awhile”.
“So, People like This Guy?”
“This would be Alyn Smith’s Partner “Jordon” who calls SNP members: “Ageing Nationalist Zombies” “
So, Hypocrisy. I think Alyn should focus closer to home, he’s not responsible for his partners opinions, but ignoring this and pointing the finger and Independence supporters is a very poor choice to make.
Lastly, my third point, is timing. Why did they write and release this the day after the papers should have been filled with joyous pictures of yesterday’s independence march?
Many think this has been timed deliberately, indeed, Neil MacKay tried to sabotage the march last year, when he was editor of the now defunt Sunday Herald. Remember this?
Indyref2 has a really good summary and reminder you can read through.
This was the catastrophic article and manipulated picture that saw the end of the Sunday Herald, UNder Neil Mackay’s editorship. Is he trying this as revenge against the Indy Movement?
In summary, I’m furious at the three of them for their stupidity, their misrepresentation and also, for aiming at the wrong targets. I’m not the only one thinking this.
They are NOT leading from the front. That’s the whole point. They are accusing their own supporters of being cybernats. Why have those 3 not called out the vicious abuse Joan McAlpine & Joanna Cherry got?Maybe cos Alyn’s partner was one?PS I’m now deciding whether or not 2vote
All of this whilst Joanna Cherry is trying to shine a light on the abuse Women get, they hijack a Unionist paper to smear the independence movement, as Joanna herself as commented on.
Hmm, go figure, eh? Almost like they had an Agenda.
P.S. The more I think about it, the more I think this is also a smear attempt against @WingsScotland and his followers.
UK Media is largely broken … what consequences does this have for #Brexit, democracy and the UK’s long term future?
You can usually learn lessons for the future, from the past, so let’s start. One harsh lesson learned from the 2014 Indepedence referendum by the losing #Yes side in Scotland, was the difficulty in getting your message out to the general public in the face of a pretty closed, biased media.
To quickly recap, we had no television or radio stations that were pro-independence (and still don’t). We had one Sunday paper that had come out for Independence; the Sunday Herald (since defunct, replaced by sunday edition of The Herald) and The National didn’t yet exist. (Incidently, there’s a whole other interesting story about the decline and demise of the Sunday Herald, which I won’t cover here, but needs documented).
I would argue that there was plenty of positive facts and information that should have led to a successful independence vote. A key issue was ordinary people not being given fair and full information by the traditional media in Scotland and people not being used to go a-looking, or indeed knowing where to look or even feeling motivated to go and start for information on their own terms (sound familiar, #Remainers?)
At that point, I’d argue many ordinary Scotland citizens simply didn’t know that they were effectively being lied to; they thought the Scottish media had their back, or at the very least wasn’t actively working against them and the Unionists used that to their advantage, not least of all, the staunchly Labour supporting Daily Record.
The infamous ‘Vow’ on the Daily Record being comprehensively shown to be a lie, has since busted that wide open in Scotland and what has happened since, is remarkable, with three big changes in the Scottish media landscape.
Firstly, people such as Murray Foote, who was the Daily Record deputy editor credited with the construction of ‘The Vow’ which made the front page on The Daily Record, have rightly in my view, been held accountable for some shocking abuses of power on a personal level. Murray for example, no longer works for the paper and is busy engaged in trying to recover his professional reputation and public image with furious backtracking and a public about-face on Independence. Good luck on that one.
Secondly, consumption of media has changed radically; readership of papers such as the Daily Record have collapsed and titles have closed, with individuals voting with their feet and wallets on who to support. The Sunday Herald, which was the first paper to support Independence, was taken over by a new Editor Neil Mackay in 2015 and first covertly, then overtly, stopped supporting independence. It’s first overt, mass alienation of it’s readership came in May 2018 after a photo story hugely misrepresented a public march in Glasgow, shortly after it hired the hugely devisive and contraversial journalist, Angela Haggerty, widely regarded as being a died-in-the-wool Scottish Labour supporter as deputy editor. After massive public outcry when she doxed and outed a young woman on twitter, Haggerty resigned in July 2018, citing ‘online abuse’ but was kept on as a columnist. The Sunday Herald has since closed in September 2018.
This has also been accompanied by viewing figures for BBC Scotland’s flagship news program, ‘Reporting Scotland’, tumbling to less than 5% of viewing adults and Radio Scotland’s main news reaching less than 2%, as reported Prof John Robertson and mentioned by Pat Kane. It’s hard to conclude anything other than people no longer feel BBC Scotland is relevent, especially as so few people believe it is trustworthy and see it attacking notable people who support Independence.
Thirdly, those still supporting Independence who wanted to get balanced facts in front of the Scottish public, decided to go down the self publishing route, to get their message out. We have a formidable array of new information channels emerging in Scotland . The daddy of them all, Wings Over Scotland (impeccable fact based journalism) has gone from strength to strength, together with Wee Ginger Dug (info with blunt humour), Indyref2 Scotland (behind the news, anti-spin) and one of my favourites, Talking Up Scotland by the rather wonderful Prof John Robertson.
Prof Robertson, particularly, delights in detailing carefully, with excellent 1-2-3 guides, how the media misreports and distorts the news in Scotland, about Scotland, whilst giving well sourced, authoritive facts about these stories. If you don’t read his work, then you should, IMHO.
So, why list all of this? What do I want to say to #Remain supporters?
Folks, you gotta get your shit together and I don’t see that happening yet. There’s several issues where you need to get better, fast.
Number 1 – Labour in England are not going to save you, Labour in Scotland are not going to save you and Labour in Wales are not going to save you.
Neither of these three parties are directly fighting Brexit. By all accounts, Corbyn wants Brexit and Labour MPs allowed the Westminster Government’s Brexit power grab to pass through Parliament. Scottish labour can’t support it for fear of looking like they support something that The SNP want to stop and god knows what Labour in Wales are doing. Their last leader caved in faster than a chocolate fireguard over the Brexit power grab and then promptly resigned. Forget Welsh Labour, they are not the vehicle to use to avoid Brexit, especially by having a Leadership contest right around the crucial Oct-Nov period in 2018 when Brexit negotiations will hit crisis point.
Labour in Scotland has also recently alienated what support it has left, by suggesting they would block the already present democratic mandate for a second independence referendum. Thats not gone down well up here. Stop hoping that Labour will save you. Not going to happen, sorry Corbynites.
Number 2 – Scotland is not going to save you (sorry, not sorry).
Sorry folks, we voted #Remain by 62% to 38% and we got ignored in our desire to stay in the single market and customs union by your opposition party (see No 1). We were also lied to by Westminster about the only way to stay in the EU was to vote Remain and that line was also pushed by UK Labour. Frankly, we have had enough. Scotland’s 5m population doesn’t achieve much against England’s 49M and we’re fed up trying. For a change we are looking after ourselves and don’t expect us to stick around and run with you off that cliff edge.
In fact, recently we’ve had very prominant people, including Vince Cable criticising Scotland for the apparant lack of support in pushing for a People’s vote. Yeah, that’s going to win us over. How about you respect the 62% of Scots that voted #Remain first mate?
Number 3 – Get your own facts, stop trusting the BBC and your press and get your truths out to the masses … organise!
Many countries have done their own assessments of the impact of Brexit on the UK, the EU and therefore opportunities and strategy for their own countries to follow, post Brexit. It is very sober reading, but this information is simply not to be found anywhere other than a few good sources on Twitter. The London based TV channels, the London based press and media have been utterly shocking in their lack of honest critique of Government policy, government reporting and actions of Brexit. They have been asleep at the wheel, whilst the medias of Ireland, France, Germany and the Netherlands have provided an abundance of information, facts and opinion on Brexit that should have been reflected back by our media.
Here’s the latest shocker, from the Australian Government as reported on Twitter. This information has been in the public domain for A YEAR and I haven’t seen this in any British publication or media channel. Here’s a few snippets.
4. The UK is likely to be the distressed negotiator, and it should be possible to extract significant concessions. https://twitter.com/EmporersNewC/status/1052459872606924800
7. There may be history between Australia and the UK, but nostalgia should not override trade realities. Australia should draw on recent developments to diversify its trade links with Europe and foster greater connections with EU, and non-EU, countries. https://twitter.com/EmporersNewC/status/1052460542588276736
16. Brexit will most likely result in a reduction of outward trade and investment with the UK. SME’s in particular will divert or delay their commitments. FDI can be expected to be reduced or diverted. Firms will have to choose between the EU and the smaller UK market. https://twitter.com/EmporersNewC/status/1052462621453164544
Frankly, the sharks are circling, but even as a #Remainer, would you know that if you relied purely on the BBC, ITV, The Daily Mail and The Times for your information? If you are pro #Brexit you won’t be looking for sources that contradict your opinions, so millions people who potentially may change their mind, as soft #Brexiters, if they knew of this new reality, will never have the opportunity to change opinion and then act on it as they simply do not know. That scares me to death.
in summary, there is no much heat and noise going on in the discussion pages on articles on BBC Online and in the press in England and Wales, but all I see is two far-apart sides becoming more polarised with few in the middle knowing what is going on and therefore being turned off from the debate.
In Scotland, we became mobilised and organised on a massive scale, as witnessed by the rise of use of social media (Scottish twitter is now absolutely dominated by well informed, vocal, pro-indy supporters engaging with people on a daily basis), throwing our purchasing power and eyeballs behind pro-indy media and away from biased Unionist sources … and getting out on to the streets.
What we’ve learned up here is that, if you want something doing, so it yourself. We saw 100k people march in Edinburgh to support Independence last weekend. That is a remarkable 2% of the Population and the biggest show of support we have had to date. That would be equivalent to 980k, almost a million people, marching through London – get out onto the streets and make so much noise that even the BBC can’t ignore you.
Several recent polls now place support for Independence equal to, or higher than support for the Union. When you take a hard Brexit into account, Independence wins. Scotland has significantly and substantially changed position on Scottish Independence since losing the referendum in 2014.
It took us four years. I’m sorry, but you don’t have that long to save the (r)UK being in the EU.
I fell in love with Doctor Who before I started school, hiding behind the sofa when it became too scary and reveling in the world of possibilities it showed a young imagination eager for excitement.
I may be a lot older, but aged 47 I firmly believe we can learn a lot about morality and how to treat others from how the Doctor solves dilemmas. Too simplistic? Let me try to persaude you, using an example closer to home, against the current issue of (some) Scottish Independence supporters rejecting Tory converts.
The episode is the two partner, of The Empty Child & The Doctor Dances.
The story is set in a time of conflict, when Britain is under attack both physically and culturally from an enemy outwith. Some of the population have reacted badly in the pressure of war, behaving unkindly to their fellow citizens, attacking strangers, not helping others and being very self centred and fomenting hatred. Sound familiar?
Yes, Boris Johnson, Nigel Farage, Tommy Robinson, I’m looking at you.
Truth is, we pretty much are in a war situation, but the root cause is ideological and not physical. Even the war is a good setting, not because of the physical conflict, but because of the meme that infects one side in the current conflict; that Britain was at its best when at war with Nazi Germany.
Let me deal with this myth first. This is complete bollocks.
People came together and helped each other to help themselves. Faced between a choice of giving in and accepting death and conquest or being inventive, resourceful and fighting back … well there isnt really much of a choice. The human instict for survival kicks in. It’s easy to be nostalgic and remember the good times, especially when that’s what you see in British and Hollywood movies, but the wars were a very dark period in human history, even in Blighty.
One small snippet from this 2016 BBC article, “Despite the Blitz spirit of World War Two, crime rose from 303,771 offences in 1939 to 478,000 in 1945”. It details looting, murder, ration abuse, blackout breaches and civil disobedience. Unlike peoples of other European nations, we weren’t imprisoned, killed and terrorised en masse.
A true test and example of humanity and Britain at it’s best would be when we came together for purely altruistic and egalitarian reasons, when we didn’t have huge external impetus forcing us to.
I’d prefer to use the example of the Olympic games in London in 2012. That was The Isles of Wonder in its truest form, with the UK welcoming strangers from all over the world, opening its arms to competitors and spectators alike from all 4 corners of the globe. How distant does that seem now.
Second point and really, my main thrust of why I thought to write this – The Empty Child character.
Children can be characterised by a lack of maturity, being motivated more by self interest and self gain and having a different perspective on the world than grown ups. They tend to think that everything is about them and for them, from their perspective, they are the most important thing in the universe. They can be curiously detached from the realities of life and believe that they deserve everything. Also, when things dont go their way, they can get very upset. None of this is meant as criticism, they are after all, just children, still learning and growing and it’s our job to help them reach their potential.
Wow, doesn’t your average Tory sound a lot like a child?
Which bringe me to Tory councillor, Ashley Graczyk. As detailed in this scotsman article, Ms Graczyk has come around to believing that Scottish Independence is the right option, in an interesting and very honest article. I commend Ashley on her journey and her honesty in speaking her truth, but the reaction from some parts of the political spectrum have me shaking my head.
Many in the #Indyref movement have tweeted that they don’t want Torys joining … that they don’t trust them, that a leopard can’t change it’s spots, etc. Shouldn’t we be delighted that a person has seen the light, had their Damascene conversion moment and is joining the good fight?
Isn’t everyone capable of being saved, of changing their mind and realising they were wrong?
In the Doctor Who series, an alien nano bot is infecting people, turning them into zombies. It strikes me that Brexit and the current hatred of immigrants and of the EU is like this science fiction infectional infection. It’s taking good people and turning them bad and fear is spreading like WIldfire.
‘Dont touch the child! You’ll become like him” wails one of the characters, ironically the child’s mother.
In the plot, one option is to destroy everything, contain the plague and protect the population. Of course, the Doctor figures out the root cause, reprograms the nano bots and gets everyone back to their former selves.
People are saved from the infection and reclaimed as human beings, to become better and more productive members of society.
If we manage to save a Tory and they see the light and can turned from being an Empty Child, shouldn’t we welcome that? 😉
Just a thought.
If you plan a visit to the Orkney islands, you should go and see the Italian Chapel. This is on your route if you arrive at the ferry terminal and head to the main islands by car.
The history of the chapel is fascinating; it was built by italian prisoners of war, kept captive on the Orkney islands after being part of an assault.
The Helix park, situated between Falkirk and Grangemouth, was originally a large stetch of waste and abandoned ground, left behind from the bygone industrial age. The ironworks on the site were long gone so in 2006, planning for a large public park began.
It is well worth a visit … and you have the Falkirk wheel nearbye too.
If you find yourself on the Isle of Skye, I thoroughly recommend an afternoon at Glen Brittle Beach. Its a great place to have a picnic, or begin a climb up the Cuillins to top Scurr Alistair.
For me, a huge attraction is the beach. There’s a lot of fine coal and peat debris that comes off the mountains and also sea coal off shore that gets washed up on the beach. The tide and currents form amazing intricate patterns in the sand that are just breath taking.
Taken from the ‘squinty bridge’, looking over the Clyde, to the Finnieston crane.
One of the nicest, most quirky places I’ve stayed at, is Invergloy lodges, near Spean Bridge. The lodges themselves are as lovely as you would expect, but it’s the artwork scattered around the lodge grounds that really delight.